Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage: A Comprehensive Comparison

If you’re looking to start a business selling products on Amazon, you may have come across the terms “online arbitrage” and “retail arbitrage.”

Both methods involve sourcing products at a low price and reselling them for a profit, but they differ in where the products are sourced from.

They are the two most popular methods of sourcing items for Amazon FBA. Most people combine both methods, in order to take advantage of various promotions.

Online arbitrage involves sourcing products from various online retailers or e-commerce platforms, while retail arbitrage involves sourcing products from physical retail stores.

One advantage of online arbitrage is that it can be done from anywhere with an internet connection, making it a flexible option for those who want to work from home or while travelling. It also allows for a wider range of products to be sourced, as online retailers often have a larger inventory than physical stores. However, it can be more difficult to find profitable products due to increased competition and the need to navigate shipping costs and minimum order quantities.

On the other hand, retail arbitrage allows for easier and more immediate access to products, as you can physically inspect them before purchasing. It also allows for the possibility of finding unique or rare items that may not be available online. However, it can be more time-consuming and require more effort to source products, as you need to physically visit stores and potentially travel to different locations to find profitable items.

Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage

If you’re looking to make money by reselling products on Amazon, you may be wondering whether to go for online arbitrage or retail arbitrage. Both methods have their pros and cons, so it’s important to weigh them up before deciding which one to use.

Definition of Online Arbitrage

Online arbitrage involves finding products online that are being sold at a lower price than they are on Amazon. You buy the products and then sell them on Amazon for a profit. This method requires you to have a good eye for spotting deals and a willingness to spend time searching for products.

Definition of Retail Arbitrage

Retail arbitrage involves finding products in physical stores that you can buy for a lower price than they are being sold for on Amazon.

You then sell the products on Amazon for a profit. This method requires you to be able to spot deals in physical stores and have the time to visit them.

But is Retail Arbitrage worth it?

Pros and Cons of Online Arbitrage

Pros

  • You can find a wide range of products online, which means you have a better chance of finding profitable deals.
  • You don’t need to leave your house to find products, which means you can save time and money on travel.
  • You can use tools like price trackers to help you find the best deals.

Cons

  • You may face competition from other online arbitrage sellers, which can make it harder to find profitable deals.
  • You may need to spend money on tools and software to help you find deals.
  • You may need to wait for products to be delivered, which can impact your ability to make a profit quickly.

Pros and Cons of Retail Arbitrage

Pros

  • You can find deals that other sellers may not be aware of, which can give you an edge over the competition.
  • You can see the products in person, which can help you make better decisions about which products to buy.
  • You can start with a small amount of money and gradually build up your business.

Cons

  • You may need to spend time and money travelling to physical stores to find products.
  • You may need to spend time waiting in line or searching for products in stores.
  • You may need to deal with returns and damaged products, which can impact your profitability.

Overall, both online arbitrage and retail arbitrage have their pros and cons. It’s important to consider which method is best for you based on your skills, resources, and preferences.

Research and Sourcing Strategies

When it comes to online arbitrage and retail arbitrage, your success largely depends on your research and sourcing strategies. In this section, we will discuss some tips and tricks to help you find profitable products to resell.

Product Research

Before you start sourcing products, it’s important to do your research. You want to find products that are in demand, but not oversaturated. Here are some ways to research products:

  • Use Amazon’s Best Seller Rank to see which products are selling well in a particular category.
  • Use tools like Jungle Scout or Helium 10 to find profitable products based on sales data and other metrics.
  • Look at customer reviews to see what people are saying about a product and if there are any common complaints or issues.

Sourcing Strategies

Once you have identified a product, you need to find a source to buy it from. Here are some sourcing strategies:

  • Retail stores: Visit retail stores like Walmart or Target to find products on clearance or sale that you can resell for a profit.
  • Online retailers: Use online retailers like Walmart.com or Target.com to find products on sale.
  • Wholesalers: Find wholesalers that sell products in bulk at a discounted price.

Scanning Apps

One of the most important tools for online and retail arbitrage is a scanning app. These apps allow you to scan barcodes and quickly see if a product is profitable. Here are some popular scanning apps:

  • Profit Bandit: This app allows you to scan products and see if they are profitable on Amazon.
  • Scoutify: This app is part of the InventoryLab suite of tools and allows you to scan products and see their sales data.
  • Amazon Seller App: This app is free and allows you to scan products and see their sales data.

Keepa

Keepa is a tool that tracks the price history of products on Amazon. This can be useful for determining if a product is consistently selling at a high price or if it’s just a temporary spike. Keepa can also help you identify trends and seasonality for certain products.

By using these research and sourcing strategies, along with scanning apps and Keepa, you can increase your chances of finding profitable products to resell through online and retail arbitrage.

Fulfillment Options

When it comes to online arbitrage and retail arbitrage, one of the most important factors to consider is fulfillment. In this section, we’ll explore the different fulfillment options available to you and the pros and cons of each.

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a popular option for both online and retail arbitrage sellers. With FBA, you send your products to Amazon’s fulfillment centers and they handle the packaging, shipping, and customer service for you. This can save you a lot of time and hassle, but it does come with some additional costs.

One of the biggest benefits of FBA is that your products are eligible for Amazon Prime, which can increase your sales. Additionally, FBA handles returns and refunds, which can be a big help if you’re not equipped to handle those tasks yourself.

However, FBA does come with some fees. You’ll need to pay for storage, fulfillment, and shipping, which can eat into your profits. You’ll also need to make sure your products are packaged and labeled correctly, which can be time-consuming.

Packaging

Whether you choose to fulfill your orders yourself or use FBA, packaging is an important consideration. Your packaging should be sturdy enough to protect your products during shipping and should also be visually appealing to your customers.

If you’re fulfilling your orders yourself, you’ll need to purchase packaging materials and handle the packaging yourself. If you’re using FBA, you’ll need to make sure your products are packaged and labeled correctly before sending them to Amazon’s fulfillment centers.

Shipping Costs

Shipping costs can be a major expense for online and retail arbitrage sellers. If you’re fulfilling your orders yourself, you’ll need to factor in the cost of shipping materials and postage. If you’re using FBA, you’ll need to pay for shipping from your supplier to Amazon’s fulfillment centers.

It’s important to consider shipping costs when pricing your products. If your shipping costs are too high, you may not be able to compete with other sellers.

Fulfillment Fees

Fulfillment fees are another important consideration when choosing a fulfillment option. If you’re fulfilling your orders yourself, you’ll need to factor in the cost of packaging and shipping. If you’re using FBA, you’ll need to pay for storage, fulfillment, and shipping.

It’s important to compare the fees for different fulfillment options to make sure you’re getting the best deal. Additionally, you’ll need to factor in your profit margins to make sure you’re still making money after paying for fulfillment.

Control

Finally, it’s important to consider how much control you want over the fulfillment process. If you’re fulfilling your orders yourself, you’ll have complete control over the packaging and shipping process. If you’re using FBA, you’ll need to trust Amazon to handle those tasks for you.

Ultimately, the fulfillment option you choose will depend on your individual needs and preferences. It’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that works best for you.

Profit Margin and Overhead Costs

When it comes to online arbitrage and retail arbitrage, it’s important to consider the profit margin and overhead costs associated with each model. Here’s a breakdown of the key factors to consider:

Profit Margin

Profit margin is the difference between the cost of acquiring a product and the price at which it’s sold. In general, online arbitrage tends to have a higher profit margin than retail arbitrage. This is because online sellers can often find products at lower prices and sell them at a higher price point on marketplaces like Amazon.

However, it’s worth noting that profit margins can vary widely depending on the product, the seller’s sourcing strategy, and other factors. In some cases, retail arbitrage may actually offer a higher profit margin than online arbitrage.

Overhead Costs

Overhead costs include any expenses associated with running your arbitrage business, such as storage fees, software subscriptions, and transportation costs. Here’s a closer look at some of the key overhead costs to consider:

Shipping Cost

One of the biggest expenses associated with online arbitrage is shipping. When you purchase products online, you’ll typically need to pay for shipping to get them to your location. Additionally, when you sell products online, you’ll need to factor in the cost of shipping them to customers.

Fuel

For retail arbitrage, transportation costs can be a significant overhead expense. If you’re driving to multiple stores to source products, you’ll need to factor in the cost of fuel. Additionally, if you’re shipping products to customers, you’ll need to factor in the cost of transportation.

Overall, both online arbitrage and retail arbitrage have their own unique costs and benefits. By carefully considering the profit margin and overhead costs associated with each model, you can make an informed decision about which approach is right for you.

Product Opportunities and Trends

Product Opportunities

When it comes to product opportunities, both online and retail arbitrage offer a wide range of options. With online arbitrage, you have access to products from all over the world, which means you can find unique items that may not be available in your local area. This can give you a competitive edge and allow you to offer products that others may not have.

Retail arbitrage, on the other hand, allows you to find products in your local area that may be in high demand. For example, if there is a new video game that has just been released, you can go to your local store and purchase it at retail price. Then, you can sell it for a higher price online, taking advantage of the demand for the product.

Trends

One trend that is becoming increasingly popular in both online and retail arbitrage is the use of private label products. Private label products are those that are manufactured by a third party but sold under your own brand name. This allows you to differentiate yourself from other sellers and build a loyal customer base.

Another trend in arbitrage is the use of software and tools to help you find the best deals. There are many tools available that can help you find products that are in high demand and selling for a high price. These tools can save you time and help you make more money in the long run.

Overall, both online and retail arbitrage offer a range of product opportunities and trends that you can take advantage of. By staying up-to-date with the latest trends and using the right tools, you can find success in the world of arbitrage.

Competition and Sales Rank

Competition

When it comes to online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, one key difference is the level of competition. With retail arbitrage, you are competing with other sellers who are buying products from the same brick-and-mortar stores as you. This means that the number of sellers and the prices they are charging can vary greatly depending on your location and the stores available to you.

On the other hand, with online arbitrage, you are competing with a much larger pool of sellers who are sourcing products from all over the world. This can make it more difficult to find profitable products, but it also means that there is a wider variety of products available and potentially less competition for certain items.

Sales Rank

Another important factor to consider when comparing online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage is sales rank. Sales rank is a measure of how well a product is selling on Amazon, with a lower number indicating higher sales.

With retail arbitrage, you can physically see and touch the products you are considering buying, which can give you a better idea of their potential sales rank. However, with online arbitrage, you must rely on the information provided by the seller or supplier, which may not always be accurate.

It is important to note that sales rank can be a fickle metric, and it is not always a reliable indicator of a product’s profitability. Other factors such as the number of sellers, the price, and the demand for the product can all impact its potential profitability.

In summary, when comparing online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, it is important to consider the level of competition and the sales rank of the products you are considering. While both methods have their pros and cons, understanding these factors can help you make more informed decisions and increase your chances of success.

Brands and Private Label

When it comes to online and retail arbitrage, understanding the difference between brands and private label products is crucial. In this section, we will explore the differences between these two types of products and how they affect your arbitrage business.

Brands

Brands are products that are manufactured and sold by a specific company. These products are often well-known and have a loyal customer base. When it comes to retail arbitrage, buying branded products can be a profitable strategy. You can purchase these products at a discount and then resell them for a higher price on Amazon or other marketplaces.

However, there are some downsides to buying branded products. For one, the profit margins may not be as high as with private label products. Additionally, you may face more competition when selling branded products, as other sellers may be selling the same products.

Private Label

Private label products are products that are manufactured by one company but sold under another company’s brand. These products are often sold exclusively by the company that owns the brand. When it comes to online arbitrage, private label products can be a profitable strategy.

One of the biggest advantages of selling private label products is that you can set your own prices and profit margins. Additionally, you can differentiate your products from your competitors by creating unique product listings and packaging. This can help you stand out from the competition and attract more customers.

However, there are some downsides to selling private label products. For one, you may need to invest more money upfront to manufacture the products. Additionally, you will need to create your own product listings and packaging, which can be time-consuming.

In conclusion, both brands and private label products can be profitable strategies for online and retail arbitrage. It is important to weigh the pros and cons of each and determine which strategy is best for your business.

Customer Service and Support

Customer Service

When it comes to customer service, both online and retail arbitrage have their pros and cons. With online arbitrage, you are typically dealing with customers through the Amazon platform. This means that Amazon handles most of the customer service issues, such as returns and refunds. However, as the seller, it is still important to provide excellent customer service to ensure customer satisfaction and positive feedback.

On the other hand, with retail arbitrage, you are dealing with customers directly. This means that you have more control over the customer service experience, but it also means that you have to handle all customer service issues yourself. This can be time-consuming and may require more resources, such as hiring additional staff.

Customer Support

In terms of customer support, online arbitrage may have the upper hand. Amazon provides a range of tools and resources to help sellers with customer support, such as the ability to track orders and manage returns and refunds. Additionally, Amazon has a dedicated customer support team that can assist sellers with any issues they may encounter.

With retail arbitrage, you may not have access to the same level of support. You may need to rely on the support provided by the manufacturer or retailer where you sourced the product. This can be problematic if the manufacturer or retailer is not responsive or helpful.

Overall, both online and retail arbitrage require good customer service and support to be successful. While online arbitrage may have more support from Amazon, retail arbitrage provides more control over the customer service experience.

Scaling Your Business

Scaling your business is important for growth and long-term success. As you start your arbitrage business, it’s important to consider how you can scale it to increase profits and reach more customers. In this section, we’ll look at how you can scale your business using online and retail arbitrage.

Business Model

Both online and retail arbitrage have their own unique advantages when it comes to scaling your business. With online arbitrage, you can easily scale your business by expanding your product offerings and reaching a wider audience. Online arbitrage allows you to source products from all over the world, giving you access to a larger inventory than with retail arbitrage.

On the other hand, retail arbitrage allows you to scale your business by expanding your reach to more retail stores. You can also increase your profits by negotiating with retailers for better deals on products. By building relationships with retailers, you can gain access to exclusive products and discounts, which can help you increase your profits.

Scalability

Scalability is an important factor to consider when scaling your arbitrage business. Online arbitrage is more scalable than retail arbitrage because you can easily expand your product offerings without having to physically visit more stores. With online arbitrage, you can simply search for products online and purchase them from the comfort of your own home.

Retail arbitrage, on the other hand, requires you to physically visit stores to source products. This can limit your scalability, as you can only visit a certain number of stores in a day. However, by building relationships with retailers and negotiating better deals, you can increase your scalability with retail arbitrage.

Customer Base

Expanding your customer base is another important factor to consider when scaling your arbitrage business. With online arbitrage, you can reach a wider audience by selling products on multiple online marketplaces, such as Amazon, eBay, and Walmart. This can help you increase your sales and profits.

Retail arbitrage, on the other hand, allows you to build relationships with local customers. By selling products in local stores, you can build a loyal customer base that will continue to purchase from you in the future. This can help you increase your sales and profits over time.

In conclusion, both online and retail arbitrage have their own unique advantages when it comes to scaling your business. By considering factors such as business model, scalability, and customer base, you can determine which type of arbitrage is best for your business and how you can scale it for long-term success.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both Online Arbitrage and Retail Arbitrage are viable business models for sourcing products to sell on Amazon. Each model has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the success of your business will depend on various factors such as your skills, resources, and preferences.

Online Arbitrage offers the convenience of being able to source products from the comfort of your own home, with the ability to access a wider range of products and suppliers. Additionally, you can easily compare prices and find deals on various online marketplaces. However, you may face competition from other sellers and may need to pay for shipping costs.

On the other hand, Retail Arbitrage allows you to physically inspect products before purchasing them and potentially find unique items that are not available online. You may also be able to negotiate better prices and take advantage of in-store sales and clearance events. However, you may need to spend more time and resources traveling to different stores and dealing with limited inventory.

Ultimately, the decision between Online Arbitrage and Retail Arbitrage comes down to your personal preferences and circumstances. It may be beneficial to try both models and see which one works best for you. Remember to always conduct thorough research and analysis before making any business decisions. Good luck!

Author
Tom P
Hi, I'm Tom Paddock! An Amazon & eBay seller, who has helped over 10,000 people start their own online business. I provide cutting-edge techniques to help sellers with Online Arbitrage, Retail Arbitrage & Wholesale on Amazon.

Leave a Comment

Learn Retail Arbitrage Website Logo

Our Mission:

To continue providing industry-leading content, to help Online Sellers increase their profitability, in the UK and United States.